Reviews

Best food best drinks best service make reservations or you are going to wait.
Wookie Warlords via google.com - Feb 20, 2019
Excellent food. The guacamole was perfect as we're my shrimp tacos. Attentive service too.
Andy Kaylie via google.com - Feb 20, 2019
Sensational tableside guacamole! Fabulous chips! Outstanding enchiladas suizas! Excellent service. Best restaurant on Long Island.
Jack via opentable.com - Feb 19, 2019
The service & food were excellent!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Michelebee via opentable.com - Feb 17, 2019
Our group went for brunch. Great sangria and solid Mexican food. Would recommend.
PJ B via google.com - Feb 16, 2019
Fabulously consistent - love everything about this place!!
Monica via opentable.com - Feb 15, 2019
Family Valentine’s Day dinner.
EdnaK via opentable.com - Feb 15, 2019
Food was delicious and our waiter Jimmy was perfect! Will definitely be back.
Mary Kelly via google.com - Feb 9, 2019
Loved the meal and the service. Very warm and welcoming staff. Delicious enchiladas, guacamole and mole sauce. Looking forward to many more visits!
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Feb 8, 2019
Great food and atmosphere ... read more
Mike Collier via google.com - Feb 8, 2019
I think that everything was awesome I just think having live music would improve the atmosphere.
SaraM via opentable.com - Feb 8, 2019
Customer service never fails and as you can see the food may look great but it also taste very good.
A Google User via google.com - Feb 4, 2019
If you like small dining rooms ...
If you like small dining rooms and getting the back of chair bashed on all night, then this is the place for you!
Kaylyn R. via yelp.com - Feb 2, 2019
Easily the best Mexican food on Long Island.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Feb 1, 2019
Wanted a nice authentic mexican ...
Wanted a nice authentic mexican dinner and my only thought was Cara Cara, and I wasn't disappointed.  Was greeted like we were old friends, eventhough we have not been there in awhile. The service, food, and atmoshere were great, and the pricing is less than what you would expect to pay for the quality meal you receive.  We started w ... read more
Trisha T. via yelp.com - Jan 31, 2019
Great cocktails, appetizers and food. Service also great.
Don Bansen via google.com - Jan 27, 2019
Awesome Mexican food, check it out!
Awesome Mexican food, check it out!
Mike Noblot via facebook.com - Jan 24, 2019
Excellent food and service. Pedro is awesome and makes a great margarita!
Mike Noblot via google.com - Jan 23, 2019
Food was excellent, skirt steak, and salmon we both great options. Service was so very good ... read more
kmpap23 via opentable.com - Jan 20, 2019
one of my favorite places can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. their plantains are amazing, always a must for a side.
Melissa Gaudio via google.com - Jan 20, 2019
Our waiter Danny was awesome. New about everything on the menu and suggested really good meals. We will for sure be coming back ... read more
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Jan 13, 2019
The food was delicious, the service was great and their prices are very reasonable. I think this was the second or third time I’ve been there, and it’s always been a positive experience. If you’re in the area and in the mood for Mexican, you can’t go wrong with Caracara.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Jan 12, 2019
Great shrimp ceviche as appetizer. My favorite entree Pollo Relleno was even better than it usually is and that’s sensational! Service was superb as usual. Best restaurant on Long Island.
Jack via opentable.com - Jan 11, 2019
Consistently good as always. I highly recommend. The service is excellent ... read more
Floyd via opentable.com - Jan 11, 2019
Always superb! CaraCara never lets me down. Fantastic ceviche! Super paiella and perfect chips. Best service anywhere.
Jack via opentable.com - Jan 8, 2019
BEST JALAPEÑO CUCUMBER MARGARITA ...
BEST JALAPEÑO CUCUMBER MARGARITA EVER! Everything was amazing and delicious from the drinks and the food. Guacamole made traditional at the table, yummy quesadilla, and definitely get the platanos. Will be back here for sure next time I'm in the area!
Kim M. via yelp.com - Jan 7, 2019
Waiters are friendly and accommodating. Food was good. They did not rush us.
Waiters are friendly and accommodating. Food was good. They did not rush us.
Emma Ford via facebook.com - Jan 7, 2019
NYE is usually a nightmare at any restaurant BUT we greeted by a super friendly hostess and seated promptly. The waiter was prompt and attentive considering the crowd. The food was EXCELLENT and the tequila list was from heaven! Dessert and hot chocolate were fantastic. Will definitely be back! Thank you for the great experience!
LoriW via opentable.com - Dec 31, 2018
My fiancé n I came here last year ...
My fiancé n I came here last year for new year's eve n it was perfect!!! He made reservations n the price was great, I believe it was $75 each, n with that we got a 5 course meal with drinks, alcoholic drinks I think we pd separately n we got the champagne toast at midnight. It was a rly nice n fun night.
Jacelyn K. via yelp.com - Dec 31, 2018
We had a wonderful experience, as always. The Sangria was delicious, as well as the chicken empanadas, enchiladas suizas, and chicken relleno. The service was very attentive and friendly. It’s such a nice spot to get upscale Mexican cuisine. Lovely place. It’s certainly a special restaurant not only for me and my family but for the s ... read more
NicolasF via opentable.com - Dec 29, 2018
Best Mexican restaurant on Long Island
The drinks, the atmosphere, the food all great. I’ve never had a bad meal here. The guacamole is great, iron skillet steak tacos are a favorite of mine. The chicken tortilla soup is great as well. Camarones tropicale has s one of my favorite dishes...More ... read more
Susan P via tripadvisor.com - Dec 21, 2018
Great Mexican place. The spicy ...
Great Mexican place. The spicy guacamole is an amazing starter. It is made table side. Had steaks for main choice with chimchuri. Very well made. Good place for team meetings. Recommended ... read more
Samir K. via yelp.com - Dec 21, 2018
Very efficient clean and friendly service. Food is amazing aswell.
marcus ammons via google.com - Dec 20, 2018
Absolutely incredible food. The short rib was so tender you could pull it apart with a fork. The skirt steak cooked to a perfect medium rare.
Jackie Langella via google.com - Dec 20, 2018
Best Mole Sauce ... read more
Rich Benner via google.com - Dec 18, 2018
The guacamole cannot be beat. It is delicious! I would say the best on Long Island !!I had lobster tacos and they were amazing!! It is very loud, but the food is great. They charge extra for everything(mango, avocado and jicama) I would still highly recommend!!
Shelley123 via opentable.com - Dec 14, 2018
Great food ... read more
steven sherman via google.com - Dec 9, 2018
This is the second time we visited CaraCara in 2 months. The food is delicious as are the cocktails, and the staff is very attentive and friendly.
TeeP via opentable.com - Dec 8, 2018
Good food, great service. Will definitely come again ... read more
William Basedow via google.com - Dec 7, 2018
Food was great, service was fast. No complaints, very good dinner ... read more
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Dec 4, 2018
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
Google+FoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip Advisor