skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

The food and selection are excellent. Never a disappointment.
mark gonzalez via google.com - Jan 24, 2022
Great food! Wonderful atmosphere. Highly recommend!
Great food! Wonderful atmosphere. Highly recommend!
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Jan 16, 2022
delicious great margarittas and great service ... read more
Scott P via google.com - Jan 14, 2022
A nice, relaxed weekday dinner in a large and airy space, over authentic and fresh Mexican food. Loved the ambience, the right volume of music, the attentiveness of wait staff, the crisp professionalism exhibited all through. Table nachos were warm and crisp, served with red and green salsa. The fajitas were great, the carne asada wa ... read more
Kundan Sen via google.com - Jan 13, 2022
Quality of food and service is always consistent ever time
Quality of food and service is always consistent ever time ... read more
JosephR via opentable.com - Jan 6, 2022
Food is always great. However I would look up the menu if you are interested in something you like and call ahead to make sure they have it.
Joe Colon via google.com - Jan 2, 2022
Always have a great dinner and experience each time we come.
Always have a great dinner and experience each time we come.
BillyC via opentable.com - Jan 1, 2022
Consistently great food, great drinks, great ambiance
Consistently great food, great drinks, great ambiance ... read more
RachaelK via opentable.com - Jan 1, 2022
Always amazing food!
Always amazing food!
ChrisP via opentable.com - Dec 28, 2021
Great service and amazing food ... read more
Robin Browne via google.com - Dec 27, 2021
Always consistent, great food, cocktails and service
Always consistent, great food, cocktails and service ... read more
PeterV via opentable.com - Dec 22, 2021
Wow! I was pleasantly surprised with ho good this restaurant is. My partner and I went here on again and we're immediately greeted by the owner asking if he could see us. We were giving great customer service by our later and they were quick to accommodate our vegan requirements. The chips were free, including free refills throughout ... read more
Ella D via google.com - Dec 15, 2021
Great food. The drinks were also really good. Our waiter was awesome. His recommendations were good.
Great food. The drinks were also really good. Our waiter was awesome. His recommendations were good. Very friendly staff. It’s not a quite place but I like that.
JenniferW via opentable.com - Dec 10, 2021
Great staff ... read more
Toby Mullen via google.com - Dec 9, 2021
Awesome as always! Especially great pollo relleno. Perfect service as always.
Awesome as always! Especially great pollo relleno. Perfect service as always.
Jack via opentable.com - Dec 6, 2021
Good food and ambiance. Always happy with the food here. Service always nice. Staff is friendly.
Jesse Miranda via google.com - Dec 4, 2021
My husband and I no longer work in the restaurant industry but we know great service when we see it. This spot never fails. We walked in on a friday night at 6:30 after being turned away at a different spot with open tables but none available for us. Every person at Caracara was accommodating! The host, the manager and our server who ... read more
Jessica L Miranda via google.com - Dec 4, 2021
Excellent experience and Food! Top Notch and Great Service!
Mike S (Mike) via google.com - Nov 28, 2021
Amazing food and great service!
amelia alvarado via google.com - Nov 25, 2021
It's easier if you makena reservation, no hassle with waiting. Food and drinks were amazing. Will definitely go back.
HESS P via google.com - Nov 22, 2021
I had lunch at CaraCara for the first time today with my friend at her recommendation. Her recommendation was spot on. The service was great, our server was very accommodating and most of all the food was delicious. I highly recommend this restaurant.
Lorraine Vicencio-Strauss via google.com - Nov 20, 2021
A nice night out with my daughter. Great food and drinks
A nice night out with my daughter. Great food and drinks ... read more
CathyB via opentable.com - Nov 20, 2021
Very good service and food will go back in the future for another dinner date with my wife
Very good service and food will go back in the future for another dinner date with my wife ... read more
willb via opentable.com - Nov 19, 2021
Amazing upscale Mexican food, great hospitality and delicious margaritas… can’t ask for more!
Christos Dimosthenous via google.com - Nov 18, 2021
Spot on food.wifes birthday and she loved it!
Michael Trela via google.com - Nov 12, 2021
Fabulous staff and food
Fabulous staff and food ... read more
AngelZ via opentable.com - Nov 12, 2021
great. nothing really like this. Such a nice space and amazing food! Guac is #1 and the tequila cream chicken is my Fav!
Joseph G via google.com - Nov 1, 2021
Very accommodating, great service, and delicious food
Very accommodating, great service, and delicious food ... read more
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Oct 31, 2021
Great food and service, can't wait to go back!!
Jeanette Nussbaum via google.com - Oct 23, 2021
pretty decor, exceptional menu options, not the typical mexican restaurant choices, yummy margaritas
pretty decor, exceptional menu options, not the typical mexican restaurant choices, yummy margaritas!
SharonJ via opentable.com - Oct 23, 2021
A rare fine dining Mexican restaurant. Friendly, professional service and delicious food.
Adam Cannava via google.com - Oct 21, 2021
Everything was wonderful! The food, service and ambiance. Kevin, our server, was attentive and frien
Everything was wonderful! The food, service and ambiance. Kevin, our server, was attentive and friendly! Definitely recommend for all occasions: date night, hang outs, family gatherings, etc.
Essie via opentable.com - Oct 17, 2021
Great food & service!
Great food & service!
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Oct 16, 2021
We were seated promptly at a perfect table for 5 in the corner. Drinks were served promptly and wait
We were seated promptly at a perfect table for 5 in the corner. Drinks were served promptly and waiter was terrific. All food orders were correct and the food was great. Waiter realized it was a birthday and brought out the sombrero for a happy birthday singalong. All in all a terrific meal with excellent service ... read more
DebraG via opentable.com - Oct 15, 2021
First time in CaraCara and YOU have to go! Amazing food, and drinks. Service was delightful and made
First time in CaraCara and YOU have to go! Amazing food, and drinks. Service was delightful and made us feel welcomed, we definitely will be back again.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Oct 15, 2021
Family dinner in a COVID safe place with attention to detail and fresh ingredients. Beautiful ambian
Family dinner in a COVID safe place with attention to detail and fresh ingredients. Beautiful ambiance and social distance. Highly recommend!
GardenCityMom222 via opentable.com - Oct 9, 2021
Celebrated my husband's 40th birthday at CaraCara. It was our first time here and when I say it exceeded my expectations. Everything from the food to the service was excellent. What a gem this restaurant is. Thank you to Tony for helping me with coordination of the event. We will definitely be back!
Saray Simo via google.com - Oct 5, 2021
Had a great meal with my wife. It was our second visit good food great service. all I would say is to add a little more gravy to the short rib which we requested and received.
David Zito via google.com - Sep 25, 2021
First time- very impressed with everything. Food was outstanding, had a few cocktails with dinner an
First time- very impressed with everything. Food was outstanding, had a few cocktails with dinner and dessert that were all great. Great vibe- we’ll def be back.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Sep 24, 2021
Our waiter was outstanding. The food was absolutely delicious. We will be back.
Our waiter was outstanding. The food was absolutely delicious. We will be back.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Sep 17, 2021
We come here often for the excellent drinks and the authentic Mexican food. The service is always go
We come here often for the excellent drinks and the authentic Mexican food. The service is always good and it is decorated with authentic decor.
veedeee via opentable.com - Sep 15, 2021
Delicious ... read more
Kara Campbell via google.com - Sep 12, 2021
Great food, great service!
Delmy Santos via google.com - Sep 3, 2021
Lightning is Just a little dark for my liking
Lightning is Just a little dark for my liking ... read more
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Aug 29, 2021
Spit on food.wifes birthday and she loved it!
Michael Trela via google.com - Aug 28, 2021
Food was delicious and our waiter was awesome. I unfortunately don't remember his name but he was nice, polite, and attentive.
Monique Suarez via google.com - Aug 28, 2021
Yummy! Great fresh guacamole 🥑 ... read more
Deborah Lyons-Birsner via google.com - Aug 14, 2021
Excellent Paella and mojitos!!
cece amayo via google.com - Aug 10, 2021
Had dinner with my wife great atmosphere ... read more
Jose Luis Flores via google.com - Aug 8, 2021
Sensational tortilla soup! Perfect pollo relleno. Spot on service. Best restaurant on Long Island.
Sensational tortilla soup! Perfect pollo relleno. Spot on service. Best restaurant on Long Island.
Jack via opentable.com - Aug 5, 2021
Best restaurant on Long Island. Super service! Perfect guacamole.
Best restaurant on Long Island. Super service! Perfect guacamole.
Jack via opentable.com - Aug 2, 2021
Forgot how much I enjoy this gem of a restaurant. I love the interior and the service and food was g
Forgot how much I enjoy this gem of a restaurant. I love the interior and the service and food was great ... read more
LionelTwain18 via opentable.com - Aug 1, 2021
Good food, wonderful staff, owners are very nice too!
diane esposito via google.com - Jul 30, 2021
Hosted colleagues from across NYS. Everyone couldn't stop raving about the service and meal. Everyth
Hosted colleagues from across NYS. Everyone couldn't stop raving about the service and meal. Everything was excellent!
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Jul 27, 2021
Great service ... read more
Matthew DiCarlo via google.com - Jul 25, 2021
Very nice Mexican restaurant with great food and drink. Their tequila selection is pretty wide and well. Service was very friendly and attentive as well. The table side guacamole is a must-have. The potion was so big that I ended up taking half of it home. They have spacious indoor dining area and also few outside seating as well.
Sayaka S via google.com - Jul 20, 2021
Food and service were great
Food and service were great ... read more
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Jul 15, 2021
All of the staff is extremely friendly and accommodating. Great food too!
All of the staff is extremely friendly and accommodating. Great food too!
SarahM via opentable.com - Jul 15, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
Google+FoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip Advisor